The messy reality behind workplace complaints
When workplace complaints become formal, it’s easy to assume something clear-cut has gone wrong.
Sometimes, it has. But in employee relations the reality is often much more nuanced than that.
We do see formal complaints and claims, but there’s usually a lot of what I call ‘rumblings’ happening before things reach that stage. And quite often, those rumblings come from misunderstandings, poor communication or processes that haven’t been properly explained.
That doesn’t mean employers can ignore them. In fact, it’s usually the opposite. Problems that seem minor at first can become much more difficult to deal with if they aren’t addressed early on.
Where the confusion starts
As mentioned, in many of the cases we see, employers aren’t directly breaching the law. What tends to come up are misunderstandings, poor communication, or documents that haven’t kept up with how the business actually runs.
Wage deductions are a good example. We often see claims where employees believe deductions have been made unlawfully, but the employer may have a right to recover certain costs, such as training or equipment. The problem usually comes back to the paperwork and communication. The employee may have forgotten or misunderstood an agreement. Alternatively, the contract / agreement may not clearly state that the amounts can be taken from wages. Both situations can result in grievances and litigation.
Payslips come up regularly as well, although for slightly different reasons. Employees will say they haven’t received one for months, but they’ve been available online the whole time. Logins have been forgotten, or no one has properly shown them where to look. It’s less about access and more about people not knowing how to use what’s there.
Working hours are often a matter of dispute, particularly where demand changes. During busy periods, employees may take on extra hours without much structure around how those hours are tracked. When things quieten down and shifts are reduced, employees start asking why their hours have dropped and how those decisions have been made. This can lead to employees alleging that they’re being discriminated or being placed at a detriment for raising concerns. Although these beliefs are usually misconceived, it can be difficult for an employer to demonstrate fairness or defend these perceptions unless processes have been followed transparently and consistently.
Why communication matters
There is often a focus on having the right policies in place, but that’s only part of the picture. Employees are often given a large amount of information when they start, but much of it is not absorbed and it’s usually only revisited when something goes wrong. This leaves a gap between what has been provided and what is actually understood.
Ongoing and open communication makes a real difference and needs to be actively encouraged by employers. Regular conversations and clear explanations help prevent small issues from becoming something more difficult to resolve.
At the same time, there is some responsibility on employees. Many of the concerns that surface later could have been addressed earlier by asking questions or clarifying how things work in practice, so it’s often a combination of both sides.
The grey areas that drive frustration
Alongside misunderstandings, there are situations where something may be legally sound but still feels unfair. This is often what sits behind the idea of ‘lawful but awful’.
We see this in claims quite often. Employees say they have been discriminated against or victimised, but the legal definitions are not always understood. Someone may feel singled out because they don’t get on with a manager or are seen as difficult. They may be treated less favourably in day-to-day decisions as a result, but it doesn’t cross into anything unlawful if there is no link to a protected characteristic or complaint of a protected nature, such as “Whistle Blowing”.
This tends to play out in everyday decisions, particularly around hours, promotions and responsibilities. Those who are more visible tend to pick up more opportunities while others miss out, sometimes without much awareness that it’s even happening.
Informal dynamics also play a big part. WhatsApp group chats are a good example. If employees set up their own social group, that may not be an issue in itself. But if managers are part of it, or work-related conversations start happening there, it can quickly feel more formal to the person who isn’t included.
Repeated over time, these experiences shape culture. Employees can feel overlooked or undervalued, and that’s often when concerns begin to escalate.
The role of managers
A consistent theme across many of these situations is the role of line managers. They’re the ones making the everyday decisions, but many have had limited training when it comes to handling people issues. That can lead to delays, inconsistency, or simply not knowing how to approach something in the moment.
In most cases, the early signs are there, they just aren’t always recognised. Regular check-ins, a good awareness of team dynamics, and the confidence to address concerns early can make a significant difference before issues develop further.
The growing impact of AI
More recently, the way complaints are raised has started to change. We are seeing a clear increase in employees using AI tools to draft grievances. On one hand, AI helps people put concerns into words, but it can make resolution more difficult at the same time.
Complaints are often much longer and filled with legislation-heavy language that is not always relevant or accurate. The main issue can become difficult to identify, which in turn makes it harder for employers to respond effectively. In contrast, when concerns are discussed in a meeting, they are often far more straightforward. An in-person conversation helps bring focus back to the real issue.
Upcoming webinars | AI, Grievances & Tribunals Series
AI is changing the way employees raise workplace concerns, and HR teams need to be ready.
In our three-part webinar series, our experts will explore how AI is influencing grievances, formal processes and Employment Tribunal claims, with practical guidance on how to respond fairly, confidently and defensibly.
Register for the series below to learn how to manage AI-influenced complaints before they escalate!
Moving forward
By the time a concern is formally raised, it’s often the result of that build-up rather than one specific issue.
For employers, the focus needs to be on how those situations are handled day to day. Making sure people understand how things work, keeping communication open, and giving managers the skills and confidence to deal with concerns early all play a big part.
In many cases, once there is a proper conversation, the issue itself is relatively straightforward. The challenge is recognising it early enough and creating the space to address it before it grows into something more complex.
